Which is your favourite Mad Secret Concert(with Helena)?

Don't say only which is your favourite Mad Secret Concert, say and the reasons!

I love both but if I had to chose I would vote for the new one cause I loved the songs more and somehow her voice was even better:) But I really love the old one too!

Well I really liked the first one, but I have to agree with Akos that the songs and Helena's voice were much better in the newest one!

I like her voice and choice of the songs more in the 1st concert.

I voted for the second because now I like much more the songs she sings in the second than in the first

I prefer the first one, because of songs choice.

I took the second one, because her voice is better, and I loved it so much when she was on stage with Marianna Gerasimidou and 15:50 because this reminds me on the great time I had when I was at Thalassa

TinaCZ wrote:I like her voice and choice of the songs more in the 1st concert.

Of the second concert I like only zombie.The other songs are so boring.

Difficult to choose.I would say the 1st due to the songs

Horgu13 wrote:

TinaCZ wrote:I like her voice and choice of the songs more in the 1st concert.

Of the second concert I like only zombie.The other songs are so boring.

Zombie is better than all the songs from the 1st and 2nd combined

Horgu13 wrote:

TinaCZ wrote:I like her voice and choice of the songs more in the 1st concert.

Of the second concert I like only zombie.The other songs are so boring.

That's an INSTULT Horgu!How can you call all those classic rock and pop songs boring?

I'm not supporting Derek but those are world-wide success songs Horgu.
And how could be El's performances boring? No way

Those songs are more like anthems!

Derek wrote:

Horgu13 wrote:

TinaCZ wrote:I like her voice and choice of the songs more in the 1st concert.

Of the second concert I like only zombie.The other songs are so boring.

That's an INSTULT Horgu!How can you call all those classic rock and pop songs boring?

I am not a rock fan.Maybe that's the reason that the songs are boring for me.And Elena is also not a rock singer for me to sing classic rock songs.

Horgu13 wrote:

Derek wrote:

Horgu13 wrote:

TinaCZ wrote:I like her voice and choice of the songs more in the 1st concert.

Of the second concert I like only zombie.The other songs are so boring.

That's an INSTULT Horgu!How can you call all those classic rock and pop songs boring?

I am not a rock fan.Maybe that's the reason that the songs are boring for me.And Elena is also not a rock singer for me to sing classic rock songs.

She's a pop rock singer currently and she can sing rock songs much better than many established rock singers.She proved that in the latest MSC but you are entitled to your own opinion Horgu, you dont have to like the songs but please dont call those legendary songs boring!

Derek wrote:

Horgu13 wrote:

Derek wrote:

Horgu13 wrote:

TinaCZ wrote:I like her voice and choice of the songs more in the 1st concert.

Of the second concert I like only zombie.The other songs are so boring.

That's an INSTULT Horgu!How can you call all those classic rock and pop songs boring?

I am not a rock fan.Maybe that's the reason that the songs are boring for me.And Elena is also not a rock singer for me to sing classic rock songs.

She's a pop rock singer currently and she can sing rock songs much better than many established rock singers.She proved that in the latest MSC but you are entitled to your own opinion Horgu, you dont have to like the songs but please dont call those legendary songs boring!

Sorry,but if a song is boring for me then I say that.Whether it is a legendary song or not.

Respect Horgu.
I also find out a lot of 'classical hits' boring.
"It's legendary songs" isn't an argument for me.

what a shame there isnt both and none of the above

for me the first one is better

The newest one.
The songs from the second MSC with Helena are more interesting and Helena's voice was more mature that in the first concert.

The first one was excellent, but the second one is a killer!

Nick Markakis wrote:The first one was excellent, but the second one is a killer!

Exactly!

I voted for the first one !!! it was the first Mad Secret Concert and we saw a different aspect from Helena. The second one is a continuation and shows how many things Helena can do !!! She was amazing !!!!!!!

the first one voted

i liked them both,can t choose

voted for the 1st one!
I love these songs...
But I really like PROUD MARY!

The 1st one. Because of the songs,style.

Derek wrote:

Nick Markakis wrote:The first one was excellent, but the second one is a killer!

Exactly!

This remembers me certain best post, indeed!

definitely the second one. not because it's more rock sounded, i also think that her voice was better somehow. and the songs were all my favorites. especially the ones like rose, zombie, wicked game and the time of my life.

The 1st

The mad secret concert 2009 is the best for me by far!! I love it!

The first one! IShe was never more beautiful than in her Eurovision year!

the first one Helena sang incredible diamond* songs like (Just Walk Away, Like A Prayer & Dont Speak)

the first one-she was younger,more beautiful,and I like most of the songs sung by her.From the second one I like only 3-4 songs